Conference Semifinal predictions: Who advances in the Audi MLS Cup Playoffs?

And then there were eight!

The Eastern Conference went nuts and saw the top three seeds eliminated in Round One. Now, the path to MLS Cup runs through Los Angeles.

Let’s look at the Conference Semifinals and see who has the edge as the Audi 2024 MLS Cup Playoffs continue.

How we got here: To be honest, I expected both of these clubs to be here when I made my predictions back in February. But after Orlando‘s start of the season, and the fact Atlanta sold Thiago Almada and Giorgos Giakoumakis midseason… this is a surprise.

Fast forward and Orlando found a way in Round One, battling in all three games against Charlotte FC‘s organized defense. Atlanta pulled off the biggest upset in MLS Cup Playoffs history, eliminating Inter Miami behind vibes and a monster series from Brad Guzan.

What comes next: Atlanta beat Orlando in both regular-season meetings this year, including on Decision Day to start their wild run. The Five Stripes are playing with confidence and without outside pressure. On the other hand, Orlando will be expected to win and are the highest remaining seed in the East. They will have more possession and Atlanta will play on the counter, where Orlando can be exposed.

One to watch: Orlando’s striker, Ramiro Enrique, hasn’t scored in his last four games. Will Oscar Pareja make a change and insert Duncan McGuire back into the lineup if he’s healthy?

Prediction: Dax McCarty‘s magical last dance (in his hometown) and Guzan’s strong play will lead Atlanta to the season sweep and onto the Eastern Conference Final.

How we got here: New York City fought back in their series vs. FC Cincinnati, then got PK shootout heroics from Matt Freese in Game 3. The Red Bulls looked rejuvenated, eliminating the Columbus Crew and stunning the defending champions.

What comes next: We finally get a Hudson River Derby in the playoffs! NYCFC swept the season series between these two clubs, with the second victory being a memorable 5-1 win on the road for NYCFC. It was 4-0 by halftime and the script was flipped, as New York City pressed Red Bulls into mistakes and punished them immediately.

One to watch: I expect this matchup to be…